The Bay Harbor Islands market

Market report · City · Oct 2026

The Bay Harbor Islands market, in numbers

Homes in Bay Harbor Islands typically sell in about 139 days, close around 3.9% under ask, prices are up 120.4% on a year ago. With 50.4 months of inventory, it’s a buyer’s market.

Median sale price

$783k

↑ +26.7% MoM↑ +120.4% YoY

8 sales closed in Oct 2026

Median rent

$4,250/mo

↓ −5.6% MoM↑ +44.1% YoY

26 leases closed in Oct 2026

Time to sell

139 days

typical days on market

Days from listing to going under contract.

Negotiation room

3.9% under ask

typical closing vs asking price

How far below the asking price homes typically close.

Months of inventory

50.4 mo

buyer’s market

Active listings divided by the monthly sales pace. Under 4 months favors sellers; over 6 favors buyers.

Gross rental yield

6.5%

yearly rent ÷ sale price

A year of median rent as a share of the median sale price.

Your questions, answered

Straight answers from Bay Harbor Islands’s closed transactions.

What does a home here cost?

The median sale closed at $783k in Oct 2026, up 120.4% on a year ago. Typical sales ranged $323k–$4.26M.

What income do you need to buy here?

At a 6.5% 30-year mortgage with 20% down, the median home runs about $6,970/mo including taxes and HOA — comfortable at a household income around $279k a year, using the 30% rule. Renting instead costs $4,250/mo.

Is now a good time to buy?

50.4 months of inventory points to a buyer’s market, and sellers are accepting about 3.9% under ask. Prices are still climbing, so waiting has a cost.

How fast do homes sell?

About 139 days from listing to contract in Oct 2026. The pace picks up toward August and slows around November.

How much room is there to negotiate?

Closings typically land 3.9% under asking price, and 36% of active listings have already reduced their price (median cut 6.3%).

When is the best time to list?

Closings peak in August and bottom out around November. Listing four to six weeks ahead of the peak historically gets the most eyes.

Is it a good rental investment?

A year of median rent ($4,250/mo) equals 6.5% of the median sale price, before fees and taxes.

Buying vs renting

Price-to-rent ratio is 15.3 — buying typically starts to beat renting after roughly 5–7 years here.

To buy — median sale price

Sale price, $

$783k↑ +26.7% MoM↑ +120.4% YoY

Oct 2026 — median $783k · 8 sales · 139 days on market

$2.5M

$5.0M

$7.5M

$10.0M

Nov ’25

Jan ’26

Mar ’26

May ’26

Jul ’26

Sep ’26

To rent — median monthly rent

Monthly rent, $

$4,250/mo↓ −5.6% MoM↑ +44.1% YoY

Oct 2026 — median $4,250/mo · 26 leases · 139.5 days on market

$10k

$20k

$30k

$40k

Nov ’25

Jan ’26

Mar ’26

May ’26

Jul ’26

Sep ’26

MedianTypical range (5th–95th percentile)3+ closingsUnder 3 (low sample)No closings (activity only)Tap or hover any month for its numbers.

What each size costs

Medians over the last 12 months.

Beds

To buy

To rent

Volume

Studio

$450k

$1,700/mo

2 closed Low sample

1 bed

$492k

$2,256/mo

103 closed

2 beds

$642k

$4,002/mo

207 closed

3 beds

$2.05M

$9,528/mo

55 closed

What sells here

Sales mix and median price by property type, last 12 months.

Condo

$780k

92% of sales · 117 closed

House

$7.93M

6% of sales · 8 closed

Townhouse

$1.02M

2% of sales · 2 closed

Low sample

Market depth

Supply and demand

Listings per month

Oct 2026 — 8 closed · 30 new · 521 active

200

400

600

Nov ’24

Feb ’25

May ’25

Aug ’25

Nov ’25

Feb ’26

May ’26

Aug ’26

ClosedActive (on market)New listings

Seasonality

Avg closings

Listings move fastest in August

Average closings by calendar month, drawn from at least two years of history.

Price-cut pressure

% of active listings

Oct 2026 — 36% of active listings cut · median cut 6.3%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

Nov ’24

Feb ’25

May ’25

Aug ’25

Nov ’25

Feb ’26

May ’26

Aug ’26

3-month averageSingle month

HOA fees per sqft

$ per sqft, monthly

$1.38 per sqft · Oct 2026

$0.50

$1.00

$1.50

$2.00

Nov ’24

Feb ’25

May ’25

Aug ’25

Nov ’25

Feb ’26

May ’26

Aug ’26

Median monthly HOA fee per square foot among closed sales.

Homes for sale in Bay Harbor Islands →Rentals in Bay Harbor Islands →

Based on 668 closed transactions over the period shown · Updated Nov 1, 2026 · Medians drawn from fewer than 3 closings are flagged as low sample.